Night of Champions 2026 delivered one of the biggest surprises of the year. Sami Zayn dethroned Cody Rhodes to become the new Undisputed WWE Champion. In a hard-fought Triple Threat Match that also featured Gunther, it was Rhodes, not The Ring General, who was pinned to bring an end to his title reign.
The finish immediately became a hot topic among fans. Many expected WWE to protect Rhodes by having Gunther absorb the loss, especially considering the Austrian powerhouse had already been embroiled in a heated rivalry with Cody in recent months. Instead, Triple H’s creative team went in the opposite direction, allowing Sami Zayn to pin The American Nightmare clean in the middle of the ring.
Thanks for the submission!
While the ending shocked many, it may have been a carefully planned decision that serves several storylines heading into SummerSlam.
That said, in this article, we look at three reasons why Cody Rhodes took the pinfall at Night of Champions 2026.
#3. WWE wanted Sami Zayn’s championship victory to feel completely legitimate
If WWE was finally going to crown Sami Zayn as the Undisputed WWE Champion, there was no better way to legitimize his victory than by having him pin the reigning champion.
Triple threat matches often end with the champion retaining or another challenger stealing a victory over the third competitor. Had Sami pinned Gunther, there would always have been an argument that he never truly beat Cody Rhodes for the championship. Instead, WWE removed all doubt.
By pinning Rhodes clean, Sami officially defeated the man who had carried the Undisputed WWE Championship for months. That instantly elevated his credibility and ensured nobody could question whether he deserved the title.
This was arguably the biggest victory of Sami’s WWE career. Thus, Triple H and his creative team made sure it felt exactly that way.
The company has increasingly emphasized decisive finishes in major championship matches over the past year. Rather than protecting every top star, WWE has shown a willingness to let clean losses happen when they strengthen the long-term story.
For Sami Zayn’s historic title victory, pinning Cody Rhodes was the strongest possible statement.
#2. WWE wanted to transition Cody Rhodes into a non-title blockbuster feud
Cody Rhodes has been at the center of the Undisputed WWE Championship picture for a long time. Although his reign was successful, keeping him in the title scene indefinitely could make the main event feel repetitive. Thus, having him lose the championship at Night of Champions gives the company the freedom to move him into another marquee rivalry.
There are several directions Triple H could now take with The American Nightmare. Cody could revisit unfinished business with Randy Orton when he returns, or even become embroiled in a completely different rivalry that doesn’t require the Undisputed WWE Championship.
None of these feuds would be possible if Cody had walked out of Night of Champions with the title still around his waist. WWE has repeatedly shown that its biggest stars don’t always need a championship to headline premium live events.
By taking the pinfall, Rhodes exits the title picture naturally while opening the door for fresh rivalries. Thus, allowing Sami Zayn to establish himself as champion and prevent the main event scene from becoming stagnant heading into the second half of 2026.
#1. Gunther still has unfinished business, and WWE protected his aura
On paper, Gunther looked like the obvious wrestler to take the fall. Instead, WWE chose to protect him while sacrificing Cody Rhodes’ title reign. That decision could indicate that Triple H has much bigger plans for The Ring General.
Unlike Cody, Gunther left Night of Champions without being pinned or submitted. He can now legitimately claim that Sami Zayn never truly defeated him. Thus, creating an immediate reason for a future championship match.
Had The Ring General been pinned, his momentum would have taken a significant hit. By allowing Cody Rhodes to absorb the loss instead, WWE preserved Gunther’s aura as one of the most dominant competitors on the roster while simultaneously creating multiple championship directions.
In many ways, Cody Rhodes was seemingly the only superstar in the match who could afford to take the fall. His legacy is already secure. He remains one of WWE‘s biggest attractions. Thus, fans are unlikely to abandon him after a single defeat.
Meanwhile, Sami Zayn desperately needed the defining victory of his career, and Gunther needed to remain protected for future marquee programs. Viewed through that lens, the booking makes perfect sense.
Cody Rhodes taking the pinfall wasn’t about weakening The American Nightmare; it was about strengthening everyone else involved. Sami Zayn became an unquestioned world champion, Gunther remained a credible threat, and WWE left itself with multiple compelling stories heading into SummerSlam.
If Triple H’s long-term booking continues to follow this pattern, Night of Champions may ultimately be remembered as the event that reshaped the Undisputed WWE Championship picture for the rest of 2026.
Get all the hottest wrestling news FIRST by clicking here
Edited by Steffi
